Family-owned in Bonita Springs since 2007

Independent insurance agency serving Naples, Bonita Springs, Estero and Fort Myers

Mobile and manufactured home, flood, homeowners and auto insurance across Southwest Florida. As an independent agency, we compare options from more than 30 carriers to help you find coverage that fits your needs and budget.

19+
Years in Southwest Florida
30+
Carriers we work with
Independent, not tied to one carrier
Ask for a review at renewal
Your independent agency We work with these carriers and partners. Availability varies by line of business, location and eligibility.
  • American Integrity logo
  • American Traditions and Sutton National (Jerger MGA) logo
  • Apex Star logo
  • Appalachian Underwriters logo
  • Citizens Property Insurance logo
  • CORE (Condo Owners Reciprocal Exchange) logo
  • Edison Insurance logo
  • Florida Peninsula Insurance logo
  • GEICO logo
  • Great Lakes and IB Green logo
  • Hartford Flood logo
  • Heritage Property & Casualty logo
  • Homeowners Choice (HCI) logo
  • Kinsale / Aspera logo
  • Manatee Insurance Exchange logo
  • Mangrove Property Insurance logo
  • Monarch Flood logo
  • Orange Insurance Exchange (Cabrillo Coastal) logo
  • Patriot Select logo
  • Praxis Reciprocal Exchange logo
  • Progressive logo
  • Root Insurance logo
  • RPS / First Rate logo
  • RT Specialty logo
  • Safe Harbor (Cabrillo Coastal) logo
  • SafePoint logo
  • Slide Insurance logo
  • Southern Oak Insurance logo
  • Tailrow Insurance Exchange logo
  • Trident Reciprocal Insurance Exchange logo
  • TypTap logo
  • Unique Insurance logo
  • Universal Property & Casualty logo
  • US Coastal (Cabrillo Coastal) logo
  • USLI logo
  • Wright Flood logo
Coverage

Insurance for your home, car and family, all in one place

Visit us
9001 Highland Woods Blvd #4
Bonita Springs, FL 34135
Why Super Insurance

Independent means more choices for you

We're not tied to a single company. We compare options from more than 30 carriers to help you find coverage that fits your needs. Then we're still here in Bonita Springs when something changes.

Family-owned

A local family serving our Southwest Florida neighbors.

30+ carriers

Ask us to review your options at renewal, not just at the start.

Local & licensed

Bonita Springs office. Florida-licensed insurance agency.

Who we are

Locally owned, family-run and independent

A family business in Bonita Springs, owned and run by the people you'll actually talk to. We founded the agency here in 2007 on a simple idea: insurance should be local, honest and easy.

Paul Hancock, owner and principal agent

Paul Hancock, CFP®

Owner & Principal Agent

Paul leads the next generation of our family agency and works with Southwest Florida homeowners, condo owners and manufactured home owners. He also owns Genesis Wealth Planning, LLC, a separate, state-registered investment adviser.

paul@superinsurancefl.com
Steve Murphy, founder and senior P&C agent

Steve Murphy

Founder & Senior P&C Agent

Steve founded Super Insurance in 2007 and has decades of experience in property and casualty insurance. He has since transitioned out of daily management and remains an active, licensed agent.

Carriers and partners we work with

American Integrity logo
American Traditions and Sutton National (Jerger MGA) logo
Apex Star logo
Appalachian Underwriters logo
Citizens Property Insurance logo
CORE (Condo Owners Reciprocal Exchange) logo
Edison Insurance logo
Florida Peninsula Insurance logo
GEICO logo
Great Lakes and IB Green logo
Hartford Flood logo
Heritage Property & Casualty logo
Homeowners Choice (HCI) logo
Kinsale / Aspera logo
Manatee Insurance Exchange logo
Mangrove Property Insurance logo
Monarch Flood logo
Orange Insurance Exchange (Cabrillo Coastal) logo
Patriot Select logo
Praxis Reciprocal Exchange logo
Progressive logo
Root Insurance logo
RPS / First Rate logo
RT Specialty logo
Safe Harbor (Cabrillo Coastal) logo
SafePoint logo
Slide Insurance logo
Southern Oak Insurance logo
Tailrow Insurance Exchange logo
Trident Reciprocal Insurance Exchange logo
TypTap logo
Unique Insurance logo
Universal Property & Casualty logo
US Coastal (Cabrillo Coastal) logo
USLI logo
Wright Flood logo
Free, no-obligation quote

Let's compare your options

Tell us what you're insuring and we'll take it from there. We compare options from the carriers we work with and follow up, usually the same business day.

Storm or claim?

Claims phone numbers and bill-pay links for the carriers we work with, in one place. Please report claims directly to your carrier.

Go to Claims and Billing