Independent insurance agency serving Naples, Bonita Springs, Estero and Fort Myers

Super Insurance of Southwest Florida is a pleasure to work with. Paul and Nathaniel are knowledgeable, personable, and helpful. They take the time to understand your needs, explain your options clearly, and answer questions without pressure. I appreciate the personal attention and care they bring to each interaction.As a family-owned business, they make the process feel straightforward and personal.

We’ve been clients of Super Insurance of SW Florida for many years and have consistently been impressed with the level of service we receive from Paul. We were originally referred to Paul by a family member, who has since recommended him to other family members and friends as well. Paul is professional, knowledgeable, responsive, and extremely efficient. He is always quick to respond to questions or requests and follows through to make sure everything is handled properly. His attention to detail and willingness to take the time to address our concerns have given us tremendous confidence in having him handle our insurance needs. What we especially appreciate is that Paul doesn’t simply provide a quote and leave it at that. He takes the time to understand our needs, explores different options, and works to find the right coverage at a competitive price. On more than one occasion, he was able to find us coverage at a reasonable price when other brokers were unable to do so. He ensures we're protected and have peace of mind. Paul is someone we’ve come to trust over the years. He is honest, dependable, and genuinely looks out for his clients. Insurance can be complicated and frustrating, but Paul makes the process straightforward and stress-free. Excellent service and truly deserving of five stars!

The winds of Hurricane Ian had hardly calmed down when Super Insurance called me to ask if I needed any claim assistance. This is not remarkable only because Paul Hancock and Nathaniel Lyles at Super Insurance ALWAYS go "above and beyond". Paul and Nathaniel are consistently highly professional, knowledgeable, helpful, and trustworthy.. Super Insurance of SWFL has had all of my property, flood and car insurance for the last 12 years. BTW, I understand that as soon as it was safe to do so, Paul drove from Estero to Florida's East coast to find electricity so that he and customers would be able to communicate by phone and internet. in a timely manner. Customer Service AAAA!